Light bulb Limited Spots Available: Secure Your Lifetime Subscription on Gumroad!

Nov 16, 2026 · 8 min read

NYC Council Votes 44-5 to Ban Surveillance Pricing

Int. 891-A would stop any business selling to New Yorkers from using an algorithm and personal data to charge different people different prices for the same thing. Loyalty tiers, student discounts and birthday coupons survive, but only on disclosed terms. The bill now sits on Mayor Zohran Mamdani's desk, and the clock starts when he signs.

Two people open the same grocery app, add the same carton of eggs, and see different prices. On Thursday, November 12, 2026, the New York City Council voted to make that scenario illegal across the five boroughs. The vote was 44-5, according to The Record, and the bill is Speaker Julie Menin's Int. 891-A. New York is the second city to pass such a ban, after Seattle signed one in October, and with eight million residents it is the largest market yet.

Key Takeaways

  • Int. 891-A passed the New York City Council 44-5 on November 12, 2026, and its Legistar record lists it as awaiting the mayor's signature.
  • Int. 891-A defines surveillance pricing as pricing set completely or in part by an algorithm that uses personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the same goods or services.
  • The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) would enforce it, with civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation, counted separately for each consumer or transaction.
  • Disclosed loyalty tiers, purchase history discounts and class discounts for groups like veterans or students remain legal, but the Council's committee report says abandoned cart discounts may no longer be permitted.
  • Int. 891-A takes effect one year after it becomes law, not one year after the vote.

What Does Int. 891-A Actually Ban?

Int. 891-A bans any business or its service provider from setting or adjusting a price for a New York City consumer using surveillance pricing. The final bill text adds a new section 20-709.1 to the city's administrative code with four prohibitions:

  • Setting or adjusting the reference price or the consumer price with surveillance pricing.
  • Advertising or publishing an offer that uses surveillance pricing.
  • Collecting, using, selling, retaining or sharing personal data "for the purpose of facilitating surveillance pricing."
  • Offering a custom discount unless it goes "uniformly to any consumer who meets the disclosed eligibility conditions or criteria."

The definition of personal data is broad: "any data that identifies or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a specific consumer or device." One carve out matters for rideshare and delivery apps: location data a consumer knowingly shares can still be used to calculate trip mileage or read local supply and demand.

Scope is where compliance teams should slow down. The ban applies to any "entity," defined as anyone "domiciled or transacting with consumers in the city." An online retailer in Ohio that sells to Brooklyn is covered. The narrower "covered business" term (small chains with fewer than 15 locations, mostly operating from physical NYC stores) only decides who gets a 30 day chance to cure a first violation.

Which Discounts Survive?

Discounts survive when they are open to everyone or tied to a narrow, disclosed slice of personal data. A "bona fide discount" is anything generally available without personal data: bulk pricing, subscribe and save, flash sales, end of season sales, price matching and rebates. A "bona fide custom discount" may use personal data, but only these kinds:

  • Loyalty programs the consumer knowingly joins, with tiers allowed if they are clearly disclosed and the purchase history behind them is not combined with other personal data.
  • Class discounts for groups like veterans, seniors, teachers or students, based on what the consumer says about themselves, "not derived or inferred by the entity from any other data."
  • Purchase history discounts from the same seller, if disclosed and not paired with other data.
  • Marketplace rules that let platforms offer one time new customer discounts or delivery fee discounts based on purchase history, without touching the base price.

What falls out is anything inferred. The Council committee report rejected an industry proposal to ban only data driven price increases, warning that businesses could infer "a consumer’s willingness to pay" and hand discounts only to people likely to shop around. It also named McDonald's, saying its loyalty program collects "geolocation, browsing history, app interactions and social media activity," and that membership "should not give the company carte blanche" to price on that data. Other exemptions cover insurance, credit pricing based on consumer reports, pricing required by federal or state law, and broker dealers pricing on assets under management.

A shopper in a New York bodega aisle holding a smartphone beside shelves fitted with digital price tags, illustrating the NYC surveillance pricing ban

How Will DCWP Enforce It?

DCWP would enforce the law through administrative cases and court actions, and the penalty math is what makes it bite. Each violation carries a civil penalty of up to $1,000, and the text says a violation counts separately "with respect to each consumer or transaction." The original May draft used escalating tiers of $150, $300 and $1,000; the amended version jumps straight to the $1,000 ceiling.

An algorithm that quotes personalized prices to 10,000 New York shoppers in one week could, on the bill's own counting rule, face up to $10 million in penalties before restitution. That is the exposure the Partnership for New York City, a business group, warned about in its June testimony, calling per violation penalties at scale "a punitive enforcement environment." The Council raised them instead.

The amended bill also lets DCWP seek actual damages for consumers, lets the city ask the state Supreme Court for injunctions and restitution, and gives the Corporation Counsel subpoena power to investigate. What it does not include is a private right of action. In June, DCWP Commissioner Sam Levine, who ran the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection when it began investigating surveillance pricing, told The American Prospect that "our agency and the administration strongly believes a private right of action should be added to the bill." It was not. Enforcement stays with the city alone.

How Does NYC Compare to State Laws?

New York City's ban covers far more of the economy than Maryland's. Maryland's HB 895 limits the ban to food retailers and delivery services, as we covered in Maryland and Connecticut Ban Surveillance Pricing and in our look at Maryland's loyalty program loopholes. NYC covers every good and service sold to a city consumer, online or in person.

The more interesting comparison is with Albany. The state legislature passed the One Fair Price Act (S.8623B/A.9349B) in June 2026, which would swap New York's 2025 disclosure rule for an outright ban. The Record reports it has sat on Gov. Kathy Hochul's desk for months. If she signs, New York businesses could answer to two overlapping bans, the "untenable dual-compliance burden" the Partnership predicted.

California has tried its own routes, from the AB 2564 ban proposal to a state investigation of retailers. Federally, the FTC proposed a policy statement in August 2026 saying undisclosed personalized pricing "is likely to constitute an unfair or deceptive act or practice," drawing 4,597 comments, according to the Council's report.

What This Means for Your Inbox

The loyalty program definition lists "signing up for a mailing list" and "registering for promotional communication" as ways a consumer enrolls, so a newsletter signup can qualify you for a disclosed custom discount. The bill also lets businesses keep sending discounts to win back lapsed customers, "unless such consumer has opted out of such communications."

The line falls on what feeds the offer, not on the email itself. Businesses told the Council they feared losing "we miss you" and "please don’t cancel" discounts, but the bill allows custom discounts "based solely on" purchase history with that seller, including the timing of purchases and cancellations, as long as that is disclosed and not combined with other data. A win back email keyed to the date of your last order survives. The same email keyed to your browsing does not, and the committee report says discounts for items "abandoned in a consumer’s cart" may no longer be permitted. On our reading of the definition, data that "could reasonably be linked" to you or your device would include what a marketer learns from your email behavior too, though the bill never names email directly.

For compliance teams, this is a CRM audit, not only a pricing audit. Any automated email flow whose offer depends on browsing, cart contents or inferred traits, rather than purchases alone, needs to be mapped against the four allowed custom discount types. For readers, the newsletter signup coupon and the birthday code are safe; the code that appears only after you abandon a cart is the one to watch, and New York's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection is where complaints will go once the law is live.

What Should Compliance Teams Do Now?

Compliance teams have one year from the day the bill becomes law, according to the Council's plain language summary, a window stretched from 120 days in the original draft. Start with these steps:

  1. Inventory every pricing input. List each model, vendor and rule that touches price or discount for NYC consumers, including third party pricing tools.
  2. Map each discount to a bucket. Label it a bona fide discount, one of the four custom discount types, or neither. Anything in neither needs to change.
  3. Separate data stores. Purchase history used for loyalty tiers cannot be "paired, combined, or cross-referenced" with other personal data, so check what your loyalty engine actually joins.
  4. Write disclosures. Tier rules and purchase history discounts must be disclosed clearly and conspicuously.
  5. Build the request process. Businesses that use personal data in pricing or offer custom discounts must let consumers "request and receive information regarding what personal data is considered" in a price, and must hand those procedures to DCWP on request.
  6. Review vendor contracts. Service providers are liable when they show reckless disregard, so pricing vendors have a reason to push back.

Consumers get a new tool too. Mamdani, who backed the bill, said in remarks quoted by The Record that "when corporations use your personal data to decide what you pay, you only stand to lose." Once the law is in force, asking a retailer what data set your price becomes a legal right in the city, not a favor.

Stop Email Tracking in Gmail

Spy pixels track when you open emails, where you are, and what device you use. Gblock blocks them automatically.

Try Gblock Free for 30 Days

No credit card required. Works with Chrome, Edge, Brave, and Arc.