Light bulb Limited Spots Available: Secure Your Lifetime Subscription on Gumroad!

Nov 17, 2026 · 8 min read

Italy Fines Meta €805M Over Facebook Camera Roll Access

Italy's data protection authority says the Facebook app for Android reached into the photo galleries of about 20 million Italian users to power a suggestions feature that was switched on by default, behind a permission prompt that never named it. The legal hook is not the GDPR but the ePrivacy rule that treats your phone as part of your private sphere.

Facebook offers to post the beach photo you took this morning. To make that offer, the app had to look through your gallery first. On November 14, 2026, Italy's Garante per la protezione dei dati personali decided that looking was the problem. It fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million, roughly $886 million according to The Record, for reading photos, videos and their metadata on Android phones without specific consent.

Key Takeaways

  • The Garante fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million on November 14, 2026, an amount the regulator puts at about 0.47% of the group's global turnover.
  • Facebook's Android feature called Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook, available since 2023, accessed gallery photos, videos and metadata under a single app wide permission, and it was on by default.
  • Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code, which transposes the EU ePrivacy Directive, is the provision Meta broke, so the GDPR one stop shop did not apply and the Irish regulator did not take the case.
  • Meta has 60 days to turn the feature off by default for everyone, including people who already granted access, and to ask for separate, specific consent.
  • Meta says it strongly disagrees, calls the fine disproportionate, and plans to appeal.

What Did the Garante Find?

The Garante found that Facebook for Android asked for gallery access once, for the whole app, and then used that access for a feature users were never told about. According to the regulator's press release (English version included), its technical analysis established three things:

  • Gallery access was requested through one permission that "applies across the entire app covering multiple features with different requirements."
  • The permission prompt was preceded by a generic notice about enabling other features, which did not tell people they were also authorizing camera roll suggestions.
  • The suggestions feature was set to on by default.

The Garante added the line that explains why the case matters beyond Facebook. When the permission is given in full, it wrote, it "allows the app to access the entire photo library on the device, usually on a permanent basis, without the user or the Authority being able to verify what information is actually being used."

The investigation started in July 2025 after a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection center in Bolzano. Roughly 16 months later, it ended in the fine.

Which App and Which Feature Were Fined?

Only the Facebook app for Android is named in the decision, and only one feature: Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook. Instagram and iPhones are not mentioned.

Meta's own Help Center page for the feature describes it as using basic metadata, such as when a photo was taken or whether it was marked as a favorite, to suggest posts from your camera roll while you scroll.

Two things were explicitly left out of this case. The proceeding did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI, which Meta denies. And it did not cover a newer feature launched in 2026 that processes camera roll content in the cloud. That one is a separate product: Meta's April 2026 announcement presents it as opt in, and says it suggests edits, collages and videos made from your gallery. The Garante says it reserves the right to investigate the cloud feature separately.

An Android phone on a cafe table in Rome with gallery photos lifting out of the screen through an open padlock toward a cloud, a judge's gavel beside it, illustrating Italy's fine against Meta over Facebook camera roll access

Why Is This an ePrivacy Fine and Not a GDPR Fine?

The Garante used Article 122 of Italy's Data Protection Code, the national transposition of the EU ePrivacy Directive, because the core act was reading information stored on a user's device. That rule, in the regulator's words, protects "the smartphone as part of the individual’s private sphere." Any access to what the phone holds requires free and informed consent, "regardless of whether data is transmitted or any harm occurs."

That last clause is the heart of it. Meta did not need to upload a single photo to break the rule. Reading the gallery on the phone was enough.

The choice of law also decided who got to rule. Meta argued that the case belonged to Ireland's Data Protection Commission, its lead authority under the GDPR. The Garante rejected that, noting that ePrivacy has no one stop shop mechanism. France's CNIL used the same logic in September 2025 when it fined Google €325 million over ads inserted between Gmail messages and cookies placed without consent. In its decision summary, the CNIL wrote that the GDPR cooperation mechanism "is not intended to apply" to cookie and electronic prospecting cases, which fall under ePrivacy.

How Big Is €805 Million?

€805 million is large for a single national regulator, though not the largest privacy penalty Meta has faced in Europe. The Record calls it one of the biggest fines the Garante has ever issued. A few comparisons put it in proportion:

  • It is about 2.5 times the CNIL's €325 million ePrivacy fine against Google.
  • It is still below the €1.2 billion GDPR fine Ireland's DPC imposed on Meta on May 12, 2023 over transfers of Facebook data to the US, according to the DPC's decision page.
  • Spread across the roughly 20 million affected Italian Android users, it works out to about €40 per person.
  • It is 805 times the €1 million the Garante fined Facebook in June 2019 over the Cambridge Analytica data, according to the Garante's 2019 release.

The Garante weighed scale, the duration of a violation still ongoing for people who have not updated the app or already granted the permission, an unnamed 2019 decision against the company, and a poor level of cooperation during the investigation. Changes Meta made after the complaint counted in its favor, but the Garante judged them late and limited to people who update the app.

What Does Meta Have to Change, and What Does It Say?

Meta must, within 60 days, ask for consent through a separate request specific to the feature and keep the feature off by default, even for people who already gave permission. It must also explain what the feature does and how to turn it off. If the deadline passes without compliance, the feature cannot run for anyone who has not given valid consent. Meta must report the steps it has started within 30 days and the measures it has adopted within 90.

Meta is fighting it. A spokesperson told Il Fatto Quotidiano (translated from Italian) that the company strongly disagrees with the Garante's assessment of the facts and its application of the law, and considers the amount disproportionate. The statement describes the feature as a simple tool that helps people post photos and videos, adds that users must grant a device permission before it can work and can change that permission at any time in settings, and ends: "We intend to appeal."

What This Means for Your Inbox

Article 122 is the same provision the Garante relies on in its 2026 guidelines for email marketing and open tracking, where reading information from a recipient's device also requires consent. The Meta decision shows how far the Garante will push that principle, and how much it is willing to charge when a company bundles consent.

For compliance teams, the lesson is about scope. One broad permission collected for one purpose does not cover a second feature that reuses it, and a default set to on is not consent. The same reasoning shows up across Italian enforcement this year, from this case to the Garante's €5.5 million fine against BBVA for ignoring a marketing opt out. It also echoes Meta's trouble earlier this year over Instagram photos used by default for AI images, a pattern of features switched on first and explained later.

Because ePrivacy has no one stop shop, any EU national regulator can act directly when an app or service reads data stored on devices in its country. Ireland is no longer the only door.

How Do You Stop Facebook From Reading Your Camera Roll?

You can turn off the suggestions inside Facebook and limit the app's gallery permission in Android itself; doing both is safest. Labels can vary by app version.

Turn off camera roll suggestions in Facebook

  1. Open the Facebook app and tap Menu.
  2. Tap Settings & privacy, then Settings.
  3. Under Preferences, tap Camera roll sharing suggestions.
  4. Switch off Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook.

Meta's Help Center also lists a shortcut: tap Create at the top of Facebook, choose Story, tap the settings gear in the top right, then Camera roll settings. If you opted in to the 2026 cloud feature, Meta says you can turn it off from the same camera roll settings.

Limit the app's photo permission in Android

  1. Open Settings and tap Apps.
  2. Tap Facebook (use See all apps if it is not listed).
  3. Tap Permissions, then Photos and videos.
  4. Choose Don't allow, or on Android 14 and later, allow only the photos you pick.

These steps follow Google's Android Help guide to app permissions. The selected photos option comes from Android 14's partial photo access, which lets you grant an app specific images rather than your whole library. Meta's help page notes that older Android versions only offer all or nothing. To audit every app at once, go to Settings, then Security & Privacy, then Privacy, then Permission manager, and open Photos and videos.

What Happens Next?

Meta's appeal will test whether national regulators can use ePrivacy to reach a company whose GDPR cases run through Dublin. If the Garante's jurisdiction holds, expect other authorities to frame device access cases the same way. The separate look at the 2026 cloud feature is still open. Watch the Garante's press releases for the 30 and 90 day reports, and check your own phone settings today rather than waiting for the new consent prompt to arrive.

Stop Email Tracking in Gmail

Spy pixels track when you open emails, where you are, and what device you use. Gblock blocks them automatically.

Try Gblock Free for 30 Days

No credit card required. Works with Chrome, Edge, Brave, and Arc.