Light bulb Limited Spots Available: Secure Your Lifetime Subscription on Gumroad!

Oct 28, 2026 · 9 min read

Buttondown Email Tracking Is Off by Default: How to Block It

Buttondown is the small, independent newsletter tool many developers and indie writers pick precisely because it does not track by default. That default is real. But each writer can flip it, and when they do, every open and click is tied to you by name. Here is how to tell which kind of Buttondown newsletter you are reading.

Buttondown email tracking is mostly a no, with one big qualifier. The company's open tracking documentation says "Open tracking is opt-in, and it only applies to emails sent after you turn it on," and the click tracking page says the same about links. So a fresh Buttondown newsletter sends you plain email. The qualifier: once a writer checks the box, the pixel and the rewritten links both carry your subscriber ID, and Buttondown's marketing invites the writer to "Dive into opens, clicks, and other subscriber behaviors." The tracking is opt in for the writer, not for you.

Key Takeaways

  • Buttondown's documentation says both open tracking and click tracking are opt in for the newsletter author and apply only to emails sent after they are turned on.
  • Buttondown's open pixel loads from buttondown.com/o/ followed by an email ID and a subscriber ID, so a fired pixel identifies the individual reader.
  • Buttondown's tracked links go through buttondown.com/c/ with the same two IDs before redirecting, unless the writer uses a custom tracking domain or tags a link with do_not_track=true.
  • February 6, 2022 is when Buttondown split its single tracking toggle into four checkboxes, so a writer can track opens without clicks, and the company said "everything remains off by default."
  • Buttondown is not on Gblock's named tracker list as of October 28, 2026; Gblock would rely on its generic small image check for the pixel, which we did not test against a live Buttondown email.
A writer at a wooden desk composing a newsletter on a laptop in morning window light, illustrating Buttondown email tracking

Does Buttondown Track Your Email Opens and Clicks?

Only if the writer turned tracking on. Buttondown's analytics feature page says it outright: "our analytics are off by default." Its pitch to writers is choice: "Some of you want to track as much as you reasonably can. Others don’t want to track anything at all."

That puts Buttondown at the opposite end from the platforms we have audited in this series. Our Substack tracking investigation and the Beehiiv audit both found tracking running unless someone acts. Buttondown flips the burden: the writer has to act to start tracking.

Since 2022, the choice has not been all or nothing. Buttondown's granular tracking settings post from February 6, 2022 says "you'll see the tracking setting replaced with four checkboxes," and that "everything remains off by default." A writer can count opens and leave links untouched, or the reverse.

How Does the Buttondown Tracking Pixel Work?

It is a single image at the end of the email whose address names you. The open tracking docs show the exact markup Buttondown adds:

<img src="https://buttondown.com/o/{email_id}/{subscriber_id}" alt="Open tracking pixel" />

"When a subscriber opens your email, that tracking pixel will be loaded," the page says. The path carries two values, which issue it was and which subscriber received it. There is no aggregate mode where the pixel is shared by everyone on the list. Every copy is personal.

Two details from that markup are useful to a reader:

  • The alt text gives it away. If images are blocked in your client, a tracked Buttondown email may show the words "Open tracking pixel" where the image would be. That is about as honest as a tracker gets.
  • The host is Buttondown's own. We checked on October 28, 2026 that buttondown.com/o/ answers requests. The docs describe no option to move the pixel to a writer's domain.

Buttondown is candid about accuracy. The docs say it "tries to detect automated open events," call that "an imperfect science," and admit "we are largely at the mercy of clients like Gmail or Outlook." For background on why opens are noisy, see our explainer on open tracking vs click tracking.

What Happens When You Click a Buttondown Link?

With click tracking on, your click passes through Buttondown before reaching the destination. The click tracking documentation says Buttondown will "rewrite all links in your email to go through a proxy URL," and gives the shape:

https://buttondown.com/c/{email_id}/{subscriber_id}/https://google.com

Notice that the real destination sits in plain sight at the end of the URL. Hover over a link in Gmail and you can read where it goes, and who it says you are, before clicking. Buttondown "will record that they clicked on the link," then forwards you on.

Three wrinkles change what you see:

  • Custom tracking domains. Writers on a custom domain can use one "to keep tracked links branded with your domain." Then the link points at the newsletter's own subdomain, and the buttondown.com/c/ pattern disappears.
  • Per link opt outs. "If you add the query parameter do_not_track=true to a link, it will not be tracked." A writer can exempt individual links even with tracking on.
  • Web archive clicks. A May 2025 Buttondown changelog entry says clicks from archived copies of an issue are tracked too when click tracking is on. Reading the web version is not automatically untracked.

What Does a Buttondown Writer See About You?

A writer with tracking on can see your individual opens and clicks, not just list totals. The analytics page offers "a closer look into an individual reader's behavior," and the subscriber ID in both URLs is what makes that possible. Buttondown's analytics API guide maps opens to an opened event and clicks to a clicked event, which writers can pull programmatically or feed into automations.

The same guide confirms the off switch is real: "If Tracking is not enabled, the request will still be successful but will not return any data." No tracking, no events, even through the API.

What Buttondown logs alongside each event is less clear. Its public docs do not list IP address or user agent fields for opens or clicks. Its privacy policy, last updated April 1, 2026, says it collects data "such as your IP address, browser and device characteristics, operating system, language preferences" and may use "web beacons and pixels," but it does not separate newsletter readers from Buttondown's own customers. Any web request reveals an IP address to the server, so assume Buttondown sees yours when a pixel or link fires outside Gmail's proxy.

What Does Gmail Already Hide?

Gmail fetches images through its own proxy, so Buttondown's pixel sees Google's servers instead of your IP. Google's image help page says "Senders can’t use image loading to get information about your computer or location," then concedes "senders may know whether you've opened an email that has an image." With a subscriber ID in the path, that is exactly the leak that matters here.

Clicks get no such protection. Your browser follows the buttondown.com/c/ link directly. Buttondown's docs do not mention Apple Mail Privacy Protection, so we cannot say how its counts treat Apple's automatic image loads.

Why Newsletter Readers Should Care

An opt in default protects you only from writers who never flip it. You cannot see a newsletter's settings, and Buttondown does not show readers a badge for tracked lists. The writer of a niche technical newsletter knows exactly which subscriber read issue 40 three times and clicked the job link, if they enabled both boxes.

Here is the contrarian part. Buttondown's honest defaults make its tracked newsletters easier to spot than most. The pixel says "Open tracking pixel" in its alt text, sits on a fixed path, and the click URL shows its destination. Compare that with platforms whose links are opaque redirect tokens on a sender's branded domain, as our Ghost tracking audit describes for a self hosted newsletter stack.

How Do You Check and Block Buttondown Email Tracking in Gmail?

Check first, then block. Many Buttondown newsletters need no action at all.

  1. Hover over a link. If it starts with buttondown.com/c/, click tracking is on. A direct link to the destination usually means it is off, unless the writer uses a custom tracking domain.
  2. Look for the pixel. In Gmail on desktop, open the three dot menu and choose "Show original," then search for buttondown.com/o/. No match means no Buttondown open pixel.
  3. Ask the writer. Buttondown authors are often individuals who reply to email. Since tracking is a checkbox, a polite request can switch it off for everyone.
  4. Make Gmail ask before loading images. Settings > See all settings > Images > "Ask before displaying external images." The pixel stays dark until you choose.
  5. Use a blocker on desktop. Gblock does not name Buttondown in its tracker list today. It flags unlisted images of 150 bytes or less, the size range of a tracking pixel, and we did not confirm Buttondown's pixel size against a live email, so treat Buttondown coverage as likely but unverified. Gblock's optional link protection resolves tracked links from its own server, so the click record carries the proxy's details instead of your browser's. It is paid with a 30 day free trial and does nothing in the Gmail mobile app.
  6. Or try the alternatives. Ugly Email, PixelBlock and Trocker are free Chrome extensions that flag or block pixels from their own lists; whether they list Buttondown is something to test, not assume. Our email tracker extensions guide compares them. Proton Mail and HEY block remote tracking images at the mailbox level, which works on phones too, but means moving your newsletters to a new address.

For every option side by side, see how to block email tracking in Gmail.

What We Could Not Verify

We did not inspect a delivered Buttondown email with tracking on, so we cannot confirm the pixel's byte size, whether Gblock's generic check catches it, or how a custom tracking domain URL is shaped. Buttondown's public docs do not list per event IP or user agent fields, and say nothing about Apple Mail Privacy Protection. We also cannot tell what share of Buttondown writers enable tracking. Everything above rests on the Buttondown documentation, its blog and changelog, its privacy policy and HTTP checks as of October 28, 2026.

Stop Email Tracking in Gmail

Most Buttondown newsletters never track you, but the ones that do tie every open and click to your subscriber ID. Gblock blocks small tracking pixels and routes tracked links through its own proxy inside Gmail on desktop Chrome, for every sender at once.

Try Gblock Free for 30 Days

No credit card required. Works with Chrome, Edge, Brave, and Arc.