Nov 08, 2026 · 6 min read
Perry Johnson's $10M AG Deal: Only $300K Is Paid Upfront
On November 6, 2026, the attorneys general of New York, Connecticut, Michigan and New Jersey settled with the Perry Johnson companies over the March 2023 breach of a medical transcription vendor. The headline says $10 million. The check is $300,000.
One employee's password opened the door. Perry Johnson & Associates (PJ&A) provided coding, billing and recording services to health care organizations across the country, and in March 2023 an attacker logged into its systems remotely with a coding employee's credentials. Two months later, the company found out it had been breached because the hackers told it so.
Key Takeaways
- The Perry Johnson companies will pay at least $300,000 in penalties to four states and owe an additional $9,700,000 only if they fail to meet the agreement's terms, according to the New York Attorney General.
- The March 2023 breach exposed records tied to more than 13.3 million people, including approximately 4.2 million New Yorkers and approximately 107,960 Connecticut residents.
- Investigators found PJ&A did not require multifactor authentication for remote access, stored protected health information in unencrypted files, and ran monitoring software that recorded the intrusion without alerting anyone.
- The settlement requires an information security program, multifactor authentication, encryption, password and asset management, and annual risk assessments consistent with HIPAA.
- The upfront penalty works out to about 2 cents per affected person, so the enforceable value sits in the security terms and the suspended $9.7 million behind them.
What Is the Perry Johnson Settlement?
The Perry Johnson settlement is a four state agreement that resolves an investigation into the 2023 PJ&A breach, with New York, Connecticut, Michigan and New Jersey as the coalition. It binds five entities: Perry Johnson & Associates, Inc., Perry Johnson, Inc. (PJI), Perry Johnson & Associates Coding, Inc., Perry Johnson & Associates Radiology, Inc., and Medical Transcription and Coding, Inc.
The money splits unevenly. New York will receive at least $100,000 for roughly 4.2 million affected residents. Connecticut will receive $66,666 for 107,960 residents, per the Connecticut Attorney General's release. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport announced the same terms in a parallel release.
"PJ&A failed its basic responsibility to guard patients' data," said New York Attorney General Letitia James. The company did not respond to a request for comment, The Record reported.
How Did Hackers Get Into PJ&A?
Hackers got in with a PJ&A Coding employee's credentials, because the company did not require multifactor authentication for remote access. The New York and Connecticut releases describe the same chain of failures:
- No MFA on remote access. A single stolen password was enough to log in.
- Password harvesting. Over the following months, the attackers collected more passwords inside the network.
- Unencrypted health records. Files with personal and protected health information sat unencrypted.
- Logs nobody saw. PJI's software "identified and recorded the hacker's activity" but "was not properly configured to provide alerts to security personnel."
- Discovery by extortion. PJ&A only learned of the breach when the hackers contacted it two months later.
The stolen files held names, dates of birth, home addresses, Social Security numbers, hospital account numbers, diagnoses, insurance information, and transcription notes with lab results and medication names. In November 2023, TechCrunch reported that PJ&A told federal regulators "more than 8.95 million individuals" were affected and began notifying patients on October 31, six months after the breach. The attorneys general now count 13.3 million, roughly half again as many.
What Must the Perry Johnson Companies Change?
Any Perry Johnson company that holds protected health information must adopt the baseline controls it lacked in 2023. The New York release lists four requirements:
- A comprehensive information security program and incident response protocol.
- Standard multifactor authentication, password management, encryption and asset management safeguards.
- Annual risk assessment programs consistent with HIPAA.
- Policies governing the collection, use, retention and disposal of personal health information.
A transcription vendor that keeps years of dictated clinical notes is holding a breach in waiting. The $9,700,000 becomes payable only if the companies fail to meet these terms, which makes it a compliance bond rather than a fine.
Is $300,000 a Real Penalty?
Spread across 13.3 million people, $300,000 is about 2 cents each. When the same New York office settled with Labcorp in September over a vendor breach, we calculated about 22 cents per affected Labcorp patient. PJ&A's upfront penalty is roughly a tenth of that, for a breach that included diagnoses and medication names.
The state shares diverge too. Connecticut's $66,666 for 107,960 residents is about 62 cents per person. New York's $100,000 for 4.2 million is about 2.4 cents. A Connecticut patient's exposure was priced roughly 26 times higher than a New Yorker's in the same breach.
Compliance teams should read the $10 million headline as a $300,000 penalty with a $9.7 million trigger. The precedent is the useful part: four regulators have now written missing MFA on remote access and unalerted logging into an enforcement finding. Healthcare penalties are not always this small, either: McLaren Health is paying $14M after two ransomware attacks.
What This Means for Your Inbox
Leaked medical records make convincing phishing bait. An email that names your real hospital, your account number and a recent test reads like a genuine billing notice or a lab follow up, and the PJ&A files contained exactly those fields. Credential theft already drives the worst healthcare email breaches, and a stolen login is how this one started.
The Federal Trade Commission's guidance on medical identity theft is blunt: "Don't give your medical information to someone who calls, emails, or texts you unexpectedly." If you received a PJ&A breach notice:
- Verify any message about a bill or test result by calling the number on a statement you already have.
- Check your explanation of benefits statements: the FTC lists one for services you did not receive as a warning sign.
- Place a credit freeze with Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. The FTC confirms it is free, lasts until you lift it, and does not affect your credit score.
What Should Compliance and Security Teams Check?
Security teams should test their own environment against the three findings that turned one password into 13.3 million records. CISA states that "users who enable MFA are significantly less likely to get hacked," yet PJ&A ran remote access without it. Start here:
- Is MFA enforced on every remote access path, including contractor and coding staff accounts?
- Are files containing PHI encrypted at rest, not only the databases?
- Do your logging tools page a human when they record anomalous access, or do they only store it?
- Which vendors process your patient data, and does your contract require all of the above from them?
PJ&A's hospital clients learned the hard way that a vendor's missing controls become their patients' problem. The TriZetto breach, which took nearly a year to detect, shows the pattern is not unique to transcription vendors.