Nov 20, 2026 · 8 min read
Hertz Pays $1.55M for Ignoring Browser Privacy Opt Outs
California's privacy regulator says the Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty websites carried trackers from Meta, Google, TikTok, Criteo and other ad tech firms, and that for part of a three year window they kept sharing rental searches and identifiers even when a visitor's browser sent a Global Privacy Control signal.
You search for a weekend rental car on dollar.com. Your browser sends a signal that says do not sell or share my data. According to California's privacy regulator, for part of the period it examined, trackers on the page ignored it and kept passing rental dates and an identifier to advertising companies. On November 17, 2026, the agency, which now calls itself CalPrivacy, announced that The Hertz Corporation will pay $1.55 million and rebuild how its three rental brands handle opt outs. The same release announced a $217,987 fine against outdoor clothing maker C.C. Filson Co.
Key Takeaways
- The Hertz Corporation agreed to a $1,550,000 administrative fine in a stipulated final order (Case ENF25-001-V-HE) that the California Privacy Protection Agency Board adopted on November 6, 2026 and announced on November 17.
- CalPrivacy found that for a portion of July 1, 2023 to August 25, 2026, Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty websites did not honor Global Privacy Control signals and kept sharing data with ad tech companies and data brokers.
- Dollar.com and Thrifty.com showed cookie toggles as already off, but closing the window without pressing Save Changes reverted to defaults that allowed advertising cookies.
- Hertz must, for three years, scan its sites and apps every quarter for trackers, check for a GPC signal before loading them, audit its consent platform twice a year, and publish how many opt outs arrived by signal.
- Hertz admitted that it sold and shared personal information for targeted advertising through cookies and pixels, but neither admits nor denies the GPC, privacy policy and cookie window findings.
What Did CalPrivacy Find on Hertz.com, Dollar.com and Thrifty.com?
CalPrivacy found that Hertz sold and shared visitors' personal information for targeted advertising through cookies and pixels on its websites, then failed to stop when visitors opted out. The stipulated final order names the tracking technologies on the company's digital properties: tools from Meta, Google, Pinterest, LinkedIn, Microsoft, TikTok, the Trade Desk, LiveRamp, Adobe, Amazon, Sojern, Criteo, Wunderkind "and other AdTech companies, some of which are registered data brokers."
The order lists what they collected: "unique user identifiers and rental search parameters," and elsewhere "personal identifiers and car rental dates."
The order says Hertz has more than 600 California locations and handles the personal information of hundreds of thousands of Californians each month. The agency lists three failures:
- Ignored signals. For a portion of the relevant period, Hertz "failed to configure its digital properties to properly detect and honor consumers' opt-out preference signals" and kept selling and sharing with "multiple AdTech companies and data brokers."
- No explanation in the privacy policy. For a portion of the period, the policy did not say how Hertz processes those signals or how consumers can use one, which California regulations require of any business operating online.
- A cookie window that undid itself. On Dollar.com and Thrifty.com, the "Manage Cookies" window displayed every toggle as off. Closing it with the X, without selecting Save Changes, reverted to the default, which allowed advertising cookies.
The third finding carries a hedge in the order itself: the design "may have been confusing which would violate" the rule against confusing interactive elements. Hertz admitted the ad tech sharing itself and that it knew consumers could opt out, but "neither admits nor denies" the three violation findings.
What Is an Opt Out Preference Signal?
An opt out preference signal is a setting in your browser that tells every website you visit, automatically, that you do not want your personal information sold or shared. Global Privacy Control, or GPC, is the example the order names. The Hertz order describes it as a standard that works "by sending a standardized HTTP header and setting a JavaScript property that websites can detect." The W3C Global Privacy Control specification defines both: a Sec-GPC request header with the value 1, and a navigator.globalPrivacyControl property that scripts on the page can read.
This is not a new obligation. The order says California has required businesses to honor these signals since August 14, 2020,, a rule now in section 7025 of the regulations. Hertz's examined window opened almost three years after the duty began.
How Does the Hertz Order Compare With FedEx?
The Hertz and FedEx orders were adopted by the same Board on the same day, November 6, 2026. Our coverage of the FedEx $2.975 million settlement found the same pattern: Meta, Google and Adobe tags on a site people visit for a practical errand, GPC signals that went unheeded, and a cookie control that did not fully work. Both examined periods start on July 1, 2023. The two remedy sections share a template: quarterly tracker scans, staging and production tests, and third party contracts. Set against the FedEx order text, the Hertz terms add four things:
- Timing. Hertz "must check to see if it has received the consumer's GPC signal before loading tracking technologies that sell or share personal information." FedEx's order cites the timing rule without spelling this out.
- Test coverage. Quarterly tests must cover every tag management container, browsers and mobile platforms, server side and client side trackers, and first time visitors with no saved consent state.
- Vendor accountability. Hertz "shall not rely solely on the statements" of its service providers or consent management platform, and must independently check them at least twice a year.
- Public metrics. Both companies must publish yearly CCPA request numbers; only Hertz must separately count opt outs that came from a preference signal.
That vendor clause is the one compliance teams should read twice. CalPrivacy's Lara Kehoe Hoffman said in the release that companies "cannot ignore those choices or shift responsibility to others." A consent vendor's dashboard is not proof that opt outs work.
What Did C.C. Filson Do Wrong?
C.C. Filson Co., an outdoor clothing maker founded in 1897, had no opt out link and broken request channels, according to its own stipulated order. Its website shared identifiers and browsing history through cookies and pixels with Meta, Google, Pinterest, and two registered data brokers, Elevar and Zeta Global. There was no "Your Privacy Choices" link, and the order says none of the three request methods in its privacy policy "functioned properly": some emails went unanswered and the customer care link led to a "PAGE NOT FOUND" screen.
Filson must stop device based sales and sharing with ad tech firms within 30 days. CalPrivacy says the $217,987 fine reflects confidential financial information showing Filson could not pay a multi million dollar penalty.
Why Email Users Should Care
The Hertz order defines tracking technologies as "any scripts, cookies, pixel tags, web beacons, software development kits, or other tracking devices." That is the same mechanism that reports when you open a marketing email: an invisible image carrying an identifier. Neither order discusses email tracking, and nothing in them extends GPC to the inbox. GPC is sent by your browser to websites; a pixel in a newsletter loads through your mail client, a separate path. For a deeper look at how often signals are ignored even on websites, see our report on hospital websites that ignore GPC.
Email still matters in a second way. The Filson order shows that a privacy request sent by email can simply disappear. If you exercise your rights through a company's privacy inbox, keep the sent message, the date, and any reply. That record is your evidence if you later complain to CalPrivacy.
How Do You Turn On Global Privacy Control?
You turn on GPC by picking a browser that sends it or adding an extension that does. The Global Privacy Control project lists these options:
- Brave and DuckDuckGo browsers send GPC by default, according to the project's FAQ.
- Firefox offers GPC as an option in its settings.
- Extensions such as Privacy Badger from EFF, OptMeowt from privacy-tech-lab, and Disconnect can add the signal to other browsers.
- Back it up on sites you care about with the "Your Privacy Choices" link, and press Save on cookie windows rather than closing them.
The CalPrivacy release says the California Opt Me Out Act, which takes effect in January 2027, requires browsers operating in California to offer easy to use opt out preference signals.
A Compliance Checklist Drawn From the Hertz Order
The terms bind only Hertz, but they show what CalPrivacy considers a working opt out program. Every item below comes from the remedies and findings in the Hertz order:
- Scan every domain, subdomain and app at least quarterly and keep a current inventory of trackers that sell or share data.
- Review each new third party before onboarding and hold a CCPA compliant contract with it.
- Read the GPC signal before any advertising tag fires, and follow each tag manager's or consent platform's documented setup, including restricted data use flags for service providers.
- Test in staging and production, quarterly and whenever a new tracker is added, by inspecting network activity, tag execution and storage writes before and after an opt out.
- Audit your consent management platform yourself twice a year instead of trusting its reports.
- Explain in your privacy policy how you process opt out preference signals, and publish annual request metrics with signal based opt outs counted separately.
Hertz has 180 days from the decision to finish its process and system changes, and the fine is due within 60 days. The Record reported that Hertz did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The Bottom Line
A browser signal binding in California since 2020 was, for part of a three year window, not stopping trackers on Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty. The $1.55 million is modest; the quarterly scans, signal first tag loading and independent consent audits are what every covered business should copy. For consumers: turn on GPC, and keep receipts of emailed requests. For the broader pattern, see our analysis of big tech sites that ignore opt out signals.