Nov 19, 2026 · 8 min read
CNIL's 38 Simplified Sanctions: Cookies, Email Consent, Security
Between June and October 2026, France's data protection authority closed 38 cases through its fast track procedure, for €302,800 in fines. Cookie banners, contest forms that steered people into email marketing, weak passwords and unanswered letters made up most of the list. None of the companies will ever be named.
Most privacy enforcement news is about one big name and one big number. This one is the opposite. On 17 November 2026 the CNIL announced that it had issued 38 sanctions under its simplified procedure between June and October, worth €302,800 in total. That works out to just under €8,000 per decision. The targets include online publishers, clothing sellers and vehicle sellers, and you will never learn which ones, because the CNIL cannot name organisations sanctioned this way. Small fines, high volume: that is the point.
Key Takeaways
- France's CNIL announced on 17 November 2026 that it issued 38 simplified procedure sanctions between June and October 2026, totalling €302,800, with 23 of the cases starting from complaints.
- Cookies accounted for about a dozen sanctions, for incomplete banners and for trackers set before consent or after a refusal.
- Six organisations were sanctioned for marketing based on contest entry forms that did not collect valid consent, about a dozen for weak data security, and six for failing to cooperate with the regulator.
- Article 22-1 of the Loi Informatique et Libertés sets up the simplified procedure, in which a single member of the CNIL's restricted committee decides and the sanctioned organisation is never named.
- The CNIL's 2026 tally under this procedure now stands at 61 sanctions and €436,550 across its two announced batches, less than half of the single €900,000 fine Solocal received in 2025 for a similar email consent failure.
What Is the CNIL's Simplified Sanction Procedure?
The simplified procedure is a fast, written enforcement track the CNIL has used since 2022 for cases that raise no particular legal difficulty. According to the CNIL's procedure page, it fits cases where case law is settled, where the restricted committee has already ruled on similar facts, or where the questions of fact and law are simple.
The mechanics are short:
- One decision maker. The president of the restricted committee, or a member they designate, rules alone instead of the full committee.
- Written exchange. The organisation receives a sanction report proposing measures under Article 22-1 of the Loi Informatique et Libertés and has one month to reply.
- Limited penalties. The options are a call to order, an administrative fine, or an order to comply, possibly with a daily penalty for each day of delay.
- No names. The CNIL's glossary states that these sanctions can never be made public.
On the ceiling, the CNIL's own pages give two figures. Its July 2026 announcement says a simplified sanction cannot exceed €20,000. The procedure page now lists €20,000 for companies with turnover under €50 million and €100,000 above that, with daily penalties of up to €100 or €500 respectively. Either way, it is tiny next to the GDPR maximum of €20 million or 4% of worldwide turnover.
What Did the 38 Sanctions Cover?
The 38 sanctions fall into four groups, with approximate counts. The CNIL's November announcement describes them this way:
Cookies (about a dozen)
After online checks of sites in publishing, clothing and vehicle sales, the CNIL found banners that did not fully explain the purposes of cookies, who was responsible, or how to refuse. Some sites dropped cookies that require consent, such as advertising cookies, before the visitor did anything or after the visitor refused. The legal hook is Article 82 of the Loi Informatique et Libertés, France's ePrivacy rule on trackers.
Email and partner marketing (six)
Six organisations collected personal data through contest entry forms and then passed it to partners or used it for electronic marketing without valid consent. The forms made accepting promotional offers look like the only way to complete an entry. These cases rest on Article 6 of the GDPR and Article L34-5 of the French Postal and Electronic Communications Code, the rule that requires prior consent before sending marketing email to individuals.
Security (about a dozen)
The findings were basic: password rules so loose that a single character was enough, customer databases reached through generic accounts shared by several people, and outdated hashing functions such as SHA-1. These fall under Article 32 of the GDPR.
Failure to cooperate (six)
Six organisations simply did not answer the CNIL, either about a video system or about how they handled access and erasure requests. Cooperation with the CNIL is a legal obligation under Article 18 of the Loi Informatique et Libertés and Article 31 of the GDPR.
The approximate counts add up to about 36. Of the 38 cases, 23 began with a complaint from a member of the public.
Why Are the Fines So Small?
The fines are small because the simplified procedure is built for volume, not for deterrence through one big number. The two batches the CNIL has announced this year show the pattern. In July it reported 23 sanctions since January for €133,750, 19 of them from complaints, mostly over workplace video surveillance, cookies, and ignored access or erasure requests. In November it added 38 more for €302,800.
Side by side, three things stand out:
- The pace picked up. The second batch, covering about five months, is larger than the first, which covered about six.
- The average fine rose. It went from roughly €5,800 per sanction in the July batch to roughly €8,000 in November, an increase of about 37%.
- Complaints drive the docket. 42 of the 61 sanctions across both batches started with a complaint.
Now the contrarian part. Combined, all 61 sanctions come to €436,550. In May 2025 the CNIL fined Solocal Marketing Services €900,000 in a single decision, partly because the misleading appearance of data brokers' forms made free and unambiguous consent impossible, the same family of problem as this year's contest forms. One decision cost about twice what 61 small ones did. The simplified track is not replacing large fines. It fills the space beneath them, so a sloppy cookie banner or a pushy contest form now has a realistic chance of costing something. We covered how that Solocal case ended in our piece on the Solocal email consent injunction.
What This Means for Your Inbox
The six marketing cases are the email story here. Entered an online contest, then started getting promotions from brands you never heard of? That is the practice the CNIL sanctioned. A form that bundles the entry with consent to partner offers, or makes the offers look mandatory, does not produce the free and specific consent that French law requires before marketing email lands in your inbox.
The cookie cases matter for email too, because the same rule covers tracking pixels in messages. In its April 2026 recommendation on email tracking pixels, the CNIL tied pixels to Article 82, the provision behind this batch's cookie sanctions, and said it acted partly because of a growing number of complaints about them. The CNIL has not said that any of the 38 sanctions involved pixels. But the route these cases took, from complaint to quick written sanction, is now open to pixel complaints as well. Our earlier breakdown of the CNIL email pixel recommendation covers what it requires.
What Should Compliance Teams Check Now?
Compliance teams should check the exact failures the CNIL listed, because they are cheap for the regulator to find and sanction. The CNIL's July 2026 batch and this one point to the same checklist:
- Test refusal, not just acceptance. Under Article 82, if your banner lets people accept all cookies in one click, it must let them refuse all in one click. Load the site in a clean browser, refuse, and confirm no advertising cookies are set.
- Fix the banner text. It must state the purposes, the controller, and how to refuse or withdraw consent.
- Audit every contest and signup form. Entry must not depend on accepting partner offers, and consent to share data with partners must be a separate, unticked choice.
- Keep proof of consent. In the Solocal case the CNIL also found a failure to prove consent under Article 7 of the GDPR. If you buy or receive lists, get the original collection forms.
- Kill shared accounts and old hashing. Give each person an individual login to customer databases, enforce real password rules, and replace SHA-1.
- Answer the CNIL and your users. Reply to regulator letters, and answer access and erasure requests within one month. Six of the 38 sanctions were for silence alone.
How Do You Complain to the CNIL?
You complain to the CNIL after first contacting the organisation, then filing online or by post with your evidence attached. The CNIL's complaint guide sets out the steps:
- Go to the company first. Write to the organisation or its data protection officer, describe the problem, and keep proof.
- Wait for the deadline. The organisation must answer within one month, extendable by two months for complex requests. No answer after a month, or an incomplete one you have already contested, means you can go to the CNIL.
- Prepare the file. The complaint must be written in French, identify the organisation (name, contact details, SIREN number), include your own contact details, and attach the exchanges and the URL of the page concerned.
- File it. Use the CNIL's online complaint service, which requires an account and lets you follow your case, or write to CNIL, Service des plaintes, 3 Place de Fontenoy, TSA80715, 75334 Paris Cedex 07.
- Expect an update. The CNIL says it aims to tell you where your complaint stands within three months of filing.
Complaints are not a formality. They started 23 of these 38 cases.
Looking Ahead
Watch two things. First, the ceiling: the CNIL's procedure page already shows a €100,000 tier for companies above €50 million in turnover, which would let the fast track reach bigger brands. Second, the themes: cookies appeared in both 2026 batches, and the pixel recommendation rests on the same Article 82, so future batches are where pixel complaints would surface first.